Skip to main content
Logo for Stonecroft Inn, featuring stylized letters "S" and "C" in green and white.
  • A lobster roll topped with chives, served with lemon wedges on a wooden platter.

Visit The Best Restaurants in Mystic, CT

While there are a few classic images that may come to mind when you think about Mystic, perhaps including lighthouses, sailboats, and a young Julia Roberts, the food scene near our Ledyard Inn, has exploded in recent years with new openings and exciting preparations putting this small coastal town on the culinary map. 

Here are some of Stonecroft Inn's personal favorite restaurants in Mystic, CT. Jim has made a point of taste testing them all to make sure they live up to his recommendation.

A stylish wooden bar with leather seating, dim lighting, and a chandelier, featuring various bottles and glassware.

Port of Call

For an exceptional culinary experience from the mind of chef/owner Reneé Touponce, Port of Call and the lower bar called Dive quickly shot to the top of the list of restaurants in Mystic not to miss. The cuisine is rooted in New England culture with international influences. Voted as one of the Best Bars in America by Esquire Magazine; the cocktails are on point, too. A 2026 James Beard Award Semifinalist.

View More
A plate of lobster roll with fries, accompanied by a glass of white wine and a water glass, set on a patio table.

S & P Oyster Co.

S&P Oyster Co. is a fresh choice for those craving seafood while visiting Mystic! Taste the flavors of the sea and discover the inventive S&P plates. From seafood ambrosia to wood-grilled swordfish and deliciously warm lobster rolls, your palate will be in heaven! They also offer an extensive gluten free menu. The restaurant prides itself on using the freshest ingredients, so grab a table while you can!

View More
Grilled fish garnished with herbs and lime on a dark plate.

Shipwright’s Daughter

Helmed by James Beard Award-winning Chef, David Standridge, most recently The Shipwright’s Daughter has been honored to be named one of the Top 50 best restaurants in America by the New York Times. He’s known for championing sustainability, connecting with farmers and fishermen to serve the freshest local ingredients in his innovative preparations.

View More
A colorful platter of sushi rolls topped with sauces and garnished with greens.

Pink Basil

Delicious Asian fusion restaurant located in Olde Mystic Village serving a wide range of curries, noodles, chef specialties and sushi. A casual environment where everyone feels welcome, including your dog! They offer dine-in, take-out or delivery service.

View More
A wooden platter with assorted meats, cheeses, and a dipping sauce, accompanied by two glasses of red wine and a candle on a table.

Via Emilia

Are you dreaming of a trip to Italy for fresh pasta, seasonal ingredients, great wines and lingering enjoyment? A visit to Via Emilia could hold you over until you can make that happen. If you are looking for delicious and unique pasta dishes or veal, chicken, fish or scallops prepared with a flair, Via Emilia is the place to go.

View More
A wooden box displaying sliced roasted duck along with garnishes and sauces inside.

Han Tang Palace

Han Tang Palace is a place where a timeless story unfolds—where history and art intertwine across a thousand years. Step into a captivating journey where the past and present meet in harmony. More than just a dining space, Han Tang Palace offers an atmosphere of elegance and a culinary feast that unites the finest of Japanese and Chinese cuisine.

View More
Cozy restaurant facade with "Amalfi" sign, lit by string lights against a sunset backdrop.

Trattoria Amalfi

Nestled in the heart of Olde Mistick Village, Trattoria Amalfi invites you to savor the vibrant flavors inspired by the picturesque Italian coastline. The menu highlights the freshest local seafood and seasonal ingredients, complemented by their signature fresh pasta made in-house daily.

View More
A wooden pier leads to a cozy waterfront restaurant under a cloudy sky.

Breakwater

If you are heading to Stonington, Breakwater at Stonington Harbor is a waterfront restaurant located on the Connecticut shoreline in the Stonington Borough. It features seafood & more, specialty cocktails, stunning sunsets & views of Stonington Harbor & Fishers Island Sound. They offer gorgeous all season sunsets & a roomy bar to keep you warm in the winter!

View More
Plate of creamy fettuccine pasta topped with grated cheese.

Bravo Bravo

After a busy day visiting downtown Mystic, shopping at the Olde Mystic Village, or exploring the Mystic Seaport Museum, you'll be ready to eat! Satisfy your hunger at Bravo Bravo! They offer an amazing selection of house-made pasta, pizzas, sandwiches, and more, all in a classy joint located conveniently on East Main Street. This Italian cuisine is contemporary with classic ingredients.

View More
A freshly baked pizza with pepperoni is placed in front of a glowing wood-fired oven.

Mystic Pizza

( Yes, That Mystic Pizza! )

How could we not mention the famous Mystic Pizza? The iconic 1980s movie starring Julia Roberts and Lily Collins has made this pizzeria known to the world, and tourists flock from all over the globe to try the secret recipe! Come and taste it yourself during your Mystic getaway! In addition to choosing from a wide selection of pizza, you can also buy film merchandise!